From: Paul Nelson <pnelson2@ix.netcom.com>
[...]
>Back to work. One last comment, for those who
>want me to do CSI calculations for them:
>
>Sorry, life is short. I've already provided citations
>(Scherer 1983, 1996; Rust 1992) where such calculations
>have been done to my satisfaction.
I really want to see calculations that have been done to *Dembski's*
satisfaction, since only Dembski can reliably say whether they are bona fide
applications of his methods. Surely, as his colleague in the CSRC, it's not
too difficult for you to confirm with him that these calculations meet *his*
approval too?
>Pardon me if this
>sounds ad hominem, but I suspect it isn't CSI estimates,
>really, that you want.
It certainly is CSI estimates that I want, together with a description of
how they've been calculated. And it is Dembski's responsibility to provide
them, or else retract his claim to have detected CSI in biological
structures. Why is Dembski so quiet on this subject?
Richard Wein (Tich)
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Mon Oct 02 2000 - 13:16:45 EDT