Re:Popper's recantation

Gordon Simons (simons@stat.unc.edu)
Thu, 16 Nov 1995 12:53:59 -0500 (EST)

Walter wrote:
"Brian Harper's latest post brings nothing new, except sour grapes. There's
nothing to respond to."

It seems to me there are two things you might respond to:

1. He described some of your comments as lies. Is he right?

2. More to the point: I think it is obvious that your style, over a series
of postings, has deeply offended a fellow brother in Christ. Without
trying to offend you in the process, I would respectfully suggest that
what you call "sour grapes" is really an expression of legitimate "pain"
on his part. You do have a VERY aggressive style. One response would be
to apologize.

Gordie