I've heard this called "Last Sundayism."
The best defense of it (the concept) is Gosse's
OMPHALOS, published in 1857; I have a photocopy of the book; it
is fascinating reading. Gordon-Cromwell (?) seminary has a photocopy --
I got it from them via interlibrary loan.
The Gosse argument is, I think, irrefutable. And there is absolutely
no way to test it (that I know).
Burgy