Re: Did a forgotten naturalist beat Darwin to natural selection?, etc

From: Stephen E. Jones (sejones@iinet.net.au)
Date: Sun May 07 2000 - 01:12:15 EDT

  • Next message: Stephen E. Jones: "Re: Intelligent Design"

    Reflectorites

    Here are some excerpts from the Electronic Telegraph from 13-27 April 2000,
    with my comments in square brackets.

    Steve

    =================================================================
    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/et?ac=000113078204876&rtmo=fqrDfrMs&atmo=FFFFFFFX&pg=/et/00/4/13/ecfdar13.html
    Electronic Telegraph 13.04.00 ... Alfred Russel Wallace page - Western Kentucky
    University http://www.wku.edu/%7Esmithch/index1.htm ... Did a forgotten
    naturalist beat Darwin to natural selection? Alfred Wallace was one of the great
    Victorians - and world famous in his day. ... It is the culmination of a year's work,
    raising funds and then renovating Wallace's long-neglected grave. But it also marks
    something of a renaissance in appreciation of this extraordinary Victorian ...
    Wallace developed the theory of evolution by natural selection ... The theory,
    however, bears the name of a certain Charles Robert Darwin, who had the same
    idea and who, by contrast, now lies in all the splendour of Westminster Abbey.
    And although ... Wallace's name was eclipsed by that of Darwin, he was far from
    unknown in his time. ... despite a disadvantaged start, he turned himself into a
    professional collector, working first in the Amazon, then Indonesia - where the
    Wallace Line separates the flora and fauna of Asia and Australasia. With numerous
    scientific papers and many books to his name, he became, by the 1890s, one of the
    world's best known scientists ... "Wallace...had this extraordinary strength of
    character," .... "When he was on his way back to England in 1852 after four years
    of work collecting in the Amazon, there was a fire on the ship and he lost
    everything. ... he just turned around and said, 'Right, I think I'll go to the Malay
    Archipelago for eight years.'" It was there, in 1858, while recovering from a bout
    of malaria, that Wallace hit on the idea of evolution by natural selection to explain
    the origins of new species. Excited by his insight, he penned an essay on the
    subject to Darwin, with whom he'd struck up a correspondence several years
    earlier. On reading it, Darwin confessed to fearing that his life's work was about to
    be "smashed" into pieces - a relative unknown producing, in a succinct 40 pages,
    what appeared very much like an elegant abstract of Darwin's own unfinished and
    unpublished work. The events that followed are still being debated today. Dr
    George Beccaloni, an entomologist, also at the Natural History Museum, who
    spearheaded the effort to renovate Wallace's grave, believes something "very fishy"
    went on. Darwin sent Wallace's paper to a friend, the eminent geologist Sir Charles
    Lyell, a pillar of the scientific establishment. He in turn arranged for the paper and
    various private letters from Darwin on evolution (pre-dating Wallace's work) to be
    read out together to a meeting of the Linnean Society in July that year, establishing
    Darwin's priority on the theory. Darwin then rushed his own book, On the Origin
    of Species, into print a year later and its great success ensured that before long, his
    name alone was linked with the theory of evolution by natural selection. Some
    believe this was less than honourable on Darwin's part. Dr Beccaloni goes further,
    supporting a theory that Darwin received the Wallace paper earlier than he claims
    he did, and may have used some of his contemporary's ideas. The documentary
    evidence has been pored over for some time, but ... most serious scholars of the
    history of evolutionary theory remain unconvinced that Darwin is guilty of the
    theft of Wallace's intellectual property. With at least six major biographies of
    Wallace currently either in progress or awaiting publication, there may yet be more
    surprises in store. ... [IMHO Darwin did act less than honourably in not
    immediately forwarding Wallace's MS to Lyell for publication as requested, but
    instead prevailed on his friends Lyell and Hooker to have his abstract read jointly
    with Wallace's paper. However, the claim that Darwin plagiarised Wallace seems
    unsustainable, since the abstract of Darwin's theory is attached to a letter he wrote
    to Asa Gray in September 1857. But what is *really* interesting IMHO is the
    rehabilitation of Wallace, which implies a `demythologising' of Darwin.]

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/et?ac=000113078204876&rtmo=ln7Hwlnt&atmo=llllll1x&pg=/et/00/4/27/ecfbrai27.html
    Electronic Telegraph. 27.04.00 ... Seeing is believing - any moment now... The
    human brain lags behind the present, says new research. ... Our brains seem to
    work in a similar way to the slightly delayed broadcast of live TV shows to provide
    an opportunity for fast editing changes. ... Human perception of the outside world
    seems to be delayed by a minimum of 80 thousandths of a second. ... human brains
    seem to develop conscious awareness in an "after-the-fact fashion", analysing
    information from both before and after an event before committing to a decision
    about what happened. ... Dr Eagleman describes these results as "quite surprising".
    "It means that your brain collects information into the future of an event before it
    commits to what it thinks it saw at the time of the event," he says. ... "More
    surprises may be in store as we look for explanations in the biology of the brain
    itself." .... [More evidence of a `ghost in the machine'?]

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/et?ac=000113078204876&rtmo=ln7Hwlnt&atmo=llllll1x&pg=/et/00/4/27/ecfchik27.html
    Electronic Telegraph. 27.04.00 ... She's a lot smarter than you think Although
    chickens don't top the list of clever animals, their particular abilities are surprisingly
    impressive ... although chickens might not top the list of clever animals, their
    particular abilities are important - and sometimes surprisingly impressive. ...
    Readers may be impressed by the chicken that learnt to peck a key to obtain access
    to a perch suspended over a tank of water. It then crossed the perch, pulled a
    string three times to unlock a door, turned right at a T-junction, and jumped across
    water to reach a nestbox. ... In fact, most animals can be trained to perform
    seemingly complex tasks with the promise of a food reward. The "clever" chicken
    may not even have envisaged the final nestbox when it performed the first keypeck
    of the sequence. Dr Christine Nicol, ... has been impressed most by how they can
    teach, which has otherwise only been studied extensively in primates. ... [As more
    animals are trained to perform impressive feats, the achievements of chimps may
    not seem so special? The article also discusses suffering and emotions in animals.]

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/et?ac=000113078204876&rtmo=ln7Hwlnt&atmo=llllll1x&pg=/et/00/4/27/ecnbab27.html
    Electronic Telegraph 27.04.00 ... Babbling, the birth of language ... THE babbling
    of babies may be the same as the first words spoken by our ancestors more than a
    million years ago. Scientists have found that four basic sounds are common to
    babies around the world and are the basis of adult speech. This backs theories that
    there was one mother tongue that evolved into all other languages. ... [Support for
    the Biblical statement that all mankind once spoke the same language: "Now the
    whole world had one language and a common speech..." (Gn 11:1)? And more
    evidence against the multi-regional hypothesis.]

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/et?ac=000113078204876&rtmo=ln7Hwlvt&atmo=99999999&pg=/et/00/4/20/ecntic20.html
    Electronic Telegraph 20.04.00 ... Chaos theory may prevent heart attacks ...
    EVIDENCE of "chaos" has been found in the heartbeats of cardiac patients,
    paving the way to developing new ways to prevent an attack by "nudging" an
    ailing heart with tiny electric shocks. ... it may be possible to refine these devices
    so that tiny currents can be used well in advance of a possible attack to keep
    heartbeat on track, said Prof Robert Harrison ... [An example of how an intelligent
    designer can bring order out of chaos? It is my preferred model of the Intelligent
    Designer's intervention/guidance at strategic points in natural history that they
    were well in advance where small, well-placed changes would have foreseen
    maximum effects.]

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/et?ac=000113078204876&rtmo=ln7Hwlvt&atmo=99999999&pg=/et/00/4/20/ecfeas20.html
    Electronic Telegraph. 20.04.00 ... How the date for Easter was set many moons
    ago A ruling 1,700 years ago made Holy Week late this year - but kept science
    alive during its darkest hour .... Thanks to a Church ruling 1,700 years ago, the
    date of its most important festival is determined by an unlikely combination of the
    lunar cycle, the solar year and our tradition of dividing the year into 365 days. ...
    The efforts to predict the festival stimulated science during the Dark Ages and
    paved the way for modern astronomy. ... [Leaving aside the misnomer "Dark
    Ages", this is another example of the crucial role that Christianity played in the
    development of modern science.]

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/et?ac=000113078204876&rtmo=ln7Hwlzt&atmo=99999999&pg=/et/00/4/13/ecnmar13.html
    Electronic Telegraph. 13.04.00 ... This little meme went to market... A MARKET
    research website with a difference has been set up by a Sussex University
    researcher. The online research tool uses "memetic" theory to process responses to
    questions posed on the site. ... When it is interpreted, the information will be sold
    to companies to increase the potential of their advertising and marketing
    campaigns ... The word "meme" was coined in the Seventies by the evolutionary
    biologist Richard Dawkins, in his book The Selfish Gene, as a cultural analogue to
    a gene - in other words, any idea or fragment of an idea that can be shared..."What
    business would like to have is the technology to engineer a memetic idea or
    product that could sweep through a population. They want an idea or product that
    behaves like a mind virus - that goes non-linear and sweeps through populations
    like a measles epidemic...." ... [It seems fitting that Darwinist, that "mind virus" par
    excellence, having been appropriated by Marxism, Freudianism, Nazism, and
    `robber baron' Capitalism, has now been appropriated by "advertising and
    marketing"!]

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/et?ac=000113078204876&rtmo=ln7Hwlzt&atmo=99999999&pg=/et/00/4/13/ecnsci13.html
    Electronic Telegraph. 13.04.00 ... Why science may bring curse of immortality ...
    BETTER treatment of disease could lead to "generational cleansing" as people live
    longer, an ethical expert warned last week. The elderly could be condemned to
    death by suicide or euthanasia after an allotted lifespan as medical advances raise
    the maximum age beyond 120, according to Dr John Harris ... a side-effect of
    research to treat the diseases of old age, such as dementia, cancer and arthritis,
    could be to extend the maximum age to immortality. ... Society would have to
    make compromises, for instance by deciding that when individuals have had "a fair
    innings" they must die, either by suicide, euthanasia or even by reactivating the
    ageing process. ... "How could a society resolve deliberately to curtail healthy life
    while maintaining a commitment to sanctity of life? The contemplation of making
    sure that people who wish to go on living cannot do so is terrible indeed." ... [An
    insight into why living forever in a fallen world might be a curse and death actually
    a mercy (cf. Gn 3:22)?]
    =================================================================

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    "Setting aside the problem of the origin of ribose, the synthesis of
    nucleosides (base and sugar linked together as in present-day nucleotides)
    also poses problems. Purines react with ribose to yield the corresponding
    nucleosides in small amounts. The analogous reaction with pyrimidines
    seems hopeless. The phosphorylation of nucleosides to nucleotides can be
    done in dry-phase with relatively good yield, but all sorts of isomers with
    varying degrees of phosphorylation emerge. This lack of purity is important
    because accurate replication of a polymer depends on chemical purity."
    (Maynard Smith J. & Szathmary E., "The Major Transitions in Evolution,"
    W.H. Freeman: Oxford UK, 1995, pp.31-32).
    Stephen E. Jones | sejones@iinet.net.au | http://www.iinet.net.au/~sejones
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Sun May 07 2000 - 10:56:51 EDT