Dear list members,
Greg Billock's cogent post regarding molecular clocks is time well =
spent.=20
In contrast to the long held agreement that the rate of point =
mutations is uniform over the entire genome of an organism and that, =
therefore, nucleotide substitution rate variations among DNA regions =
reflected differential selective constraints, Wolfe, Sharpe and Li =
(Wolfe K.H., Sharp P.M., Li W.H. (1989) Mutation rates differ among =
regions of the mammalian genome. Nature 337(6204):283-285) argued that =
evidence for variations in mutation rates among regions of the mammalian =
genome were due to the differences in the timing of chromosomal =
replication within germline cells. Their observation also provide a =
mechanism to explain why some selectively neutral silent nucleotide =
substitution sites do not appear to "tick" to the same molecular clock.=20
=09
Fitch (Fitch, W.M. (1994) Molecular Clocks Are Better Than You Think. =
Journal of General Physiology 102(6):1a. ) contends that the seeming =
manege of molecular clocks can be navigated by throwing out the "false =
assumption" that there is an equal potential for change in all amino =
acid positions. Fitch argues that for any given lineage, at any point =
in it's evolutionary history (i.e., time) the numbers of amino acid =
positions subject to replacement is only a fraction of the total. As a =
consequence the probability of same-site multiple replacements is =
greater. Further, there is a "saturation phenomenon" that accounts for =
decreased relative changes as divergence time increases.
In a strong affirmation of the underlying postulate of constraint, =
Fitch claimed that data can be "consonant with a perfect clock provided =
only that we specify the number of concomitantly variable codons =
(covarions) and the rate at which the pool of covarions turns over."
There is also a rational argument to be made regarding the plausibility =
that selection is simply weaker at the at the molecular level and that, =
while selection can operate at the molecular level -- the mechanisms of =
mutation and drift predominate.
It is worthwhile to note that phenotypic changes may be due more to =
differences in gene regulation than in sequence alterations. In =
addition, many researchers who do not agree with the arguments offered =
by the molecular clock hypothesis await a deeper understanding of =
relationship between biochemical evolution and genetic differentiation =
before being able to evaluate the accuracy, reliability, and =
applicability of such clocks.=20
These reservation are, however, a long way from the misguided criticism =
of molecular clocks put forth by Denton and Behe and very far from =
being worrying to evolutionary theory.
I'll re-read the Science article titled, "Calibrating the Mitochondrial =
Clock". However, at first blush, I'm at loss to see any new criticism of =
the practical applications of molecular clock theory.
In truth the molecular clock hypothesis is tied to a troubled neutral =
theory and it is important to remember that, whenever a technique or =
hypothesis becomes detached from its theoretical underpinnings -- and =
becomes instead girded by ad hoc explanations and situational laws -- =
one would be well remanded to Tacitus: For if it is true that "the =
more corrupt the republic, the more laws multiply" -- perhaps it is =
likewise true that the more corrupt the scientific hypothesis, the more =
"explanatory mechanisms" multiply.
Best Regards,
K. Lee Lerner
Science Policy Institute
------ =_NextPart_000_01BD5967.78A31860
Content-Type: application/ms-tnef
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64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=
------ =_NextPart_000_01BD5967.78A31860--