ReMine had also asserted that Haldane's dilemma could be seen in
the operation of evolution simulations. Upon this point, I
challenged ReMine to name the simulation which showed the difficulties
of HD, to specify how such difficulties were recognized or quantified,
and basically to have the whole issue put to empirical test. I offered
to modify an existing program to use the "soft selection" described
by Peters and Colby, and then we would see if the problems went
away as Peters and Colby asserted, or remained as ReMine asserted.
ReMine did not produce the name of the simulation that he had claimed
showed the problem, nor any indication of how one recognized the
problem in a simulation. It seems to me that he missed a great
opportunity to try out his idea.
Wesley