Soulless brutes

John W. Burgeson (73531.1501@compuserve.com)
Wed, 15 Jan 1997 12:07:02 -0500

Glenn wrote, (sarcastically), "Shoot, Neanderthal built walls,pavements,
dug post-holes, made flutes, and engaged in subterranean mining. Of course
they aren't human according to large parts of old-earth Christian
apologetics because if they are, then humanity goes back possibly as far as
230,000 years ago and this is unacceptable. So we call them soulless
brutes."

Understanding your base argument, Glenn, let me suggest you read yet
another book -- Julian Jaynes' THE ORIGIN OF CONSCIOUSNESS IN THE BREAKDOWN
OF THE BICAMERAL MIND. Not that I think Jaynes "has got it right," but I do
think his thesis, that humanity was really not "aware" until a late stage
of civilization, is one which needs to be argued. If his thesis is right,
then the building of walls, the practice of music and mining, etc. are not
indicative of humans as we know them today. The thesis is very well argued,
whatever one may decide about it personally.

Burgy