Science in Christian Perspective
A NEW DECADE
Richard H. Bube
Stanford University
Stanford CA
From: JASA 22 (March 1970): 2-3.
A New Period
It is probably not possible for a scientist to look ahead into the next years
without being in some sense a prophet of gloom. What appears most
certain is that
we have passed into a new period when the increase of science and its
public glamor
are rapidly being braked to a standstill. Statistics alone demand this. If the
world's participation in science were to continue at the present rate
for several
more decades, most of the people of the world would be practicing scientists,
and most of the resources of the world would be used in scientific research by
a small fraction of the total world population in a very small fraction of the
earth.
To this intransigent fact must be added a basic disenchantment with science as
a means to the good life. For almost a century the conviction has been growing
that the insights of science have made the faith of religion impossible. Bereft
of the traditional religious basis for moral values and for simple
hope, men have
turned against science because of the role it has played in turning the joy of
life into apparent despair. This is not so much a conviction that people come
to as the result of a long and careful search of the evidence; it is part and
parcel of our cultural heritage today. Young people growing up never question
the basic premise that science makes the supernatural impossible.
Add to this the growing evidence that man's careless use of
scientific technology
is beginning to backfire on a large scale all along the line.
Environmental poisoning
is a problem that grips most of the world. Even the beneficial
results of science,
such as improvements in health and the conquest of disease, have
accentuated the
population explosion, problems that arise simply because there are
too many people
for the world to feed, or to hold without drastic changes in habits
and practices.
The effect on students is evident in decreasing enrollment in the sciences, a
situation further aggravated when a national physics journal reports
that a large
fraction of the PhD graduates in physics today already cannot find a
job In India
I am told that tens of thousands of graduate engineers are without
work in their
field.
The Application Gap
The gap between basic and applied science grows wider as more scientists become
involved in research. Most of the great public problems to which
scientific solutions
are applicable are not problems in knowledge; they are problems in how to apply
knowledge already largely available to specific problems to gain
specific results.
Only a small fraction of the results of basic research are applicable
to practical
problems at any given time. Practical applications of science build up such an
extensive technology that so much expense is invested and so much involvement
of lives and training is involved that a change from this technology requires
an improvement in a product not by a factor of two but by at least a factor of
ten. Economic factors become intricately involved in such vast enterprises and
the extent to which immediate economic considerations dictate
longrange scientific
or social goals is always a serious question.
This kind of statement is true not only of the physical sciences but they apply
at least to some extent to the biological sciences as well. I am told that far
more is known than is currently being used in medicine; the need is
for a transfer
of applied knowledge from the storehouse of basic research to the bedside. And
in a situation where a growing population is one of the greatest
concerns of the
world, research that promises a variety of ingenious ways to contribute to this
population growth by controlled aids to artificial life production must seem an
anomaly to almost anyone who thinks about the question from a broad viewpoint.
With all the promise of biological engineering to control and improve
the condition
of the human being, there is always the underlying fear that the concurrently
increased possibilities for the inhuman control of man is also increased to an
extent that makes wise men ponder.
Expected Trends
Concrete suggestions of the trends to be expected are fairly easy to make. But
in the making of them there is the vague and general impression that they are
perhaps not the important steps that will shape the future of the
world. Science
will of course continue to be done, and man's conquest of nature and an achievement
of an understanding of the natural world is an occupation that needs
no apology.
Computers will play an increasingly larger role in the management of functions
and the performance of services. They will find their way into the
homes of those
able to afford them and may well revolutionize such practices as
shopping, banking
and politics. Life-saving through organ transplant will increase in
use and advances
will he made toward the production of a variety of artificial organs
to increase
the supply and to diminish the dilemma of the choice of donors.
Practical substitutes
for the internal combustion engine, at least for short-range travelling, will
be developed in an effort to combat air pollution. Nourishing food substitutes
will be developed to stem the hunger problem.
Some of the largest scientific enterprises, such as military defense,
space travel
and nuclear research will come up against an economic barrier that will force
a change in policy regardless of the desires or intents of the
participants. Unless
investment in military defense is severely cut, and this must of
necessity include
some of the funds devoted to scientific development and technology involved in
military defense, we may not even survive the ten years that we are
here projecting
into. Isolated successes in the space venture are to be expected, but also the
growing realization that space travel by itself is a fruitless and
non-productive
waste of earth's resources; space efforts can be expected to concentrate on the
terrestrial part of space with local space stations for weather and
military purposes
primarily. The next major breakthrough in nuclear research may
require a "machine"
so expensive that it is finally ruled out and the practical decision
is enforced
that this is as far as we can afford to go.
Social Upheaval
But behind and above all these isolated events on the scientific and
medical scene,
population pressures, famine, and social upheavals can be expected on a global
level. In every part of the world there are people living who have never
enjoyed
the beneficial products of scientific technology that have
characterized the life
of the majority in this country. Still living in the ways of poverty
and personal
privation, they are becoming aware that the "good things"
of the world
may never be theirs, because these things are in the hands of men who
appear determined
(or helpless) to let the world be destroyed rather than face the major changes
in practice and policy that are called for. It is small wonder that the lives
of such people are constantly and inevitably involved in various outbreaks of
violence and social upheaval in a determined effort to reverse the current of
present affairs and preserve in their time at least some of the
things and conditions
that others have enjoyed before them. This common-place upheaval of peoples in
every country, regardless of specific motive or local cause, is a
world-wide phenomenois
that cannot he ignored, It is an upheaval that, coupled with world-wide famine
and disaster, may so dominate the future that the contributions of science and
medicine may assume only a relatively small place. And even this would in many
ways be preferable to the outcome of the "haves" of the
world deciding
(either deliberately or unconsciously) to use the power of science
and technology
to maintain their hold on the things to be enjoyed and to keep them out of the
reaching hands of the "have nots."
Science and medicine treat a world of things, of impersonal objects. This is no
slander or slur on these noble professions; it is a simple statement
of the nature
and scope of science. But when science assumes the all-important role that it
has acquired in the last half-century, the concurrent emphasis on the value of
things and a discounting of the personal and religious aspects of
human life can
have only a cumulative detrimental affect on society. The next ten years will
be a period when men realize as seldom before that their very existence as men
(and not as impersonal objects) requires more than the perspective of science,
scientific progress and the economic and political systems compatible
with these
perspectives. They will reach out desperately for some way of validating their
existence as men in a day when their humanity is daily more
threatened. They will
search for every -ism, for astrology and scientology, for mysticism and drugs,
for sensitivity training and awareness stimulation, for freedom to
"do their
own thing" while the rest of the world goes on to hell if it must.
The Answer
What they seek is what every man seeks: the knowledge of who he is, and of what
the meaning of his life is. There is an answer provided in the person of Jesus
Christ and the God who is His Father. But how important it is today
to know what
the questions are. Answers given to questions that are not asked,
seldom are accepted.
R. H. B.