Science in Christian Perspective
Thinkers Thought on Religion and Science
IRVING W. KNOBLOCH, Biology
From; PSCF 20 (December 1968): 119-120.
Since there is "nothing new under the sun" and since we all
attain our
philosophy of life by means of our senses, it would seem appropriate to quote
what others have said about various aspects of concern to the members
of our group.
Because some prominent figure has expressed an opinion upon some
topic, it should
not be automatically assumed that the speaker or writer has exactly the right
idea. We naturally will gladly accept those opinions which coincide
with ours but
one should read adverse opinions slowly to see if something useful is
not offered.*
"The great minds of science know physics deeply enough to
perceive the need
for metaphysics. But the great minds of science are few and they are reticent
people. Meanwhile the air is vocal with the noise of the hangers-on,
the laboratory
technicians, the merely engineers and the cocky young
instructors." Bernard
I. Bell in Beyond Agnosticism.
"Religion, like science, should accept the fact that it is
necessarily imperfect,
yet perfectible. The conflicts are not between science and religion but between
science and theology." George Sarton in Science, Religion and Reality.
"There are many, and in all lands, who insist upon maintaining a
reasonable
faith and in challenging both the omnicompetence of scientific materialism and
the inerrancy of religious authorities." Charles Raven in Natural Religion
and Christian Theology.
"Science will never renounce the attempt to bring everything
under a single
system of laws. Science must be monistic, for under any other
dispensation science
could not exist. The dualism of nature and super-nature is
intolerable to science."
Dean Inge in Dingle's Science and Human Experience.
"Science and religion cannot be separated because:
1) scientists are sometimes Christians and vice versa, and (2) it
invites science
to discover new things and gradually take over the field of religion. God is in
and through science-science must be a religious activity science is one aspect
of God's presence. It is a mistake to say that science has no presuppositions
and Christianity is loaded with them. Some presuppositions in science
are honesty,
integrity, hope, enthusiasm, humility, singleness of mind,
co-operation, patience
and judgment. The splendour and power of science reveals the
splendour and power
of God." C, A. Coulson in Science and Christian Belief.
"Just as religious leaders omit to tell their adherents about
the difficult
points of the Bible, so evolutionists omit the difficulties of the
theory."
Irving W. Knoblach.
"It is a fact, the significance of which cannot be exaggerated, that the
measure of the civilization which any nation has attained is the
extent to which
it has curtailed the power of institutionalized religion. Those people who are
wholly under the sway of the priesthood such as the Tibetans, Koreans, Siamese
and Caribbeans, are peoples among whom the intellectual life does not
exist."
Upton Sinclair in The Profits of Religion.
"Lutherans have run away from intellectual issues, fearing a loss of their
faith. The parochial system (school) takes our children out of life
and prepares
them for the next, another run away attitude. Those sects who have
parochial schools
have (or should) lose their influence in public instruction."
Carl H. Gross
in Our Church in the Academic Community.
"We have described scientific knowledge as dependent on
rational, empirical
confirmation in contrast to the existential validity of religious
truth. We have suggested that while scientific truth deals with things and is
therefore relatively
certain, it is also relatively lacking in significance and is highly partial in
nature. Religious truth, on the other hand, is relatively uncertain but it is
of the greatest significance to man for it deals with his ultimate concerns or
values-it attempts to come to grips with the totality of life." Joseph H.
Royce in The Scorch for Meaning. (Amer. Sci, 47:515535,1959.)
"What we need is not so much an open mind but an attitude of
distrust toward
our own ideas. Rudolph Flesch in The Art of Clear Thinking.
"Opinion, even if wrong, may stimulate thought."
John S. Mill in On the Liberty of Thought and Discussion .
"The absolute miracle of God's providential care nevertheless
remains, though
the evidence against it is overwhelming; for every instance of
providential care,
there is a negative one." Martin Heinecken in God in the Space Age.
*Some passages have been slightly paraphrased.